Shelfy vs Carrd: An Honest Comparison for Creators (2026)
Shelfy vs Carrd: An Honest Comparison for Creators (2026)
Carrd is a one-page website builder. Shelfy is a link curation platform. Honest comparison of where each tool actually fits, including the cases where neither one is right and the cases where you might want both.
If you're comparing Shelfy and Carrd, you've probably noticed they both get listed as "link in bio tools" in roundups, even though they are actually different categories of product.
Carrd is a one-page website builder. It launched in 2016, was built by indie developer AJ Lykins as a bootstrapped solo project, and remains one of the cheapest serious website builders on the market at $19 per year for the most-recommended tier. People use Carrd for landing pages, simple portfolios, pre-launch sites, contact pages, and yes, link-in-bio pages, but the tool itself isn't link-in-bio specific.
Shelfy is a link curation platform with a public bio at the core. It's free forever, built around organizing links into searchable collections with categories, tags, voting, and rich auto-fetched previews. Different category, different priorities, different price model.
Comparing them feature-by-feature without that DNA difference produces a misleading scorecard. Here's the honest version. Where Carrd wins. Where Shelfy wins. The cases where neither one is right. And the cases where you actually want both.
TL;DR, who wins for whom
Choose Carrd if you want a real one-page website with full layout control, custom forms, embedded payment widgets (Stripe, Gumroad, PayPal), or you're a designer who values pixel-level customization. The Pro Standard tier at $19 per year is genuinely one of the best deals in website building.
Choose Shelfy if you want a link-in-bio that actually organizes content rather than presenting a flat one-page layout. Categories, tags, search, voting on links, addressable sub-collections, follow + notify, and a Chrome extension for tab-saving. Free forever, every feature included.
Choose neither alone if you want both: a real website AND a curated link collection. Pair Carrd as your one-page website (or about page, or portfolio) with Shelfy as the audience-facing curation surface. They genuinely don't overlap, so running both is not redundant.
Choose nothing yet if you don't actually know what you're building. Both tools are cheap or free, but the wrong choice creates rework. A creator who picks Carrd and then realizes they need archive organization is in for a manual rebuild.
The full reasoning is below.
What each tool actually is
Marketing pages blur the lines, so let's be precise.
Carrd is a one-page website builder created by AJ Lykins in 2016. Solo-developed, bootstrapped, indie-hacker-respected. The product builds responsive single-page sites for landing pages, portfolios, pre-launch announcements, contact pages, and link-in-bio uses. It uses a block-based editor with text, image, video, button, form, and widget elements. Pricing is annual only, ranging from free to $49 per year. The product's identity is: simple, fast, cheap, designer-friendly, one-page.
Shelfy is a link curation platform launched in 2024 with a public bio at the core. It treats links as first-class objects to be organized: categories, tags, search, drag-and-drop reordering, community voting, auto-fetched previews, follow + notify, and a Chrome extension for capturing browser tabs. The public collection has two viewer-toggleable layouts (Card view with rich previews, and List view). Free forever, every feature included.
The DNA difference matters. Carrd is design infrastructure for one-page sites. Shelfy is curation infrastructure for organized link collections. They're sometimes positioned as competitors because both can serve a "link in bio" use case, but the underlying product shapes solve different problems.
Where Carrd genuinely wins
Starting here because honest comparison is the differentiation.
Full one-page website capability. Carrd builds real websites. Hero section, multi-section layouts, custom typography choices, contact forms, embedded payment widgets, image galleries, animations on scroll. If what you need is a website that happens to have your social links on it, Carrd does the website part well. Shelfy doesn't try to be a website builder.
Pixel-level design control. Carrd's editor lets you control spacing, alignment, typography, color palettes, and section structure with meaningful precision. For designers who care about visual presentation at a level beyond "rich preview cards," this matters. Pro Plus at $49 per year even allows custom code embedding and code export.
Custom forms and lead capture. Pro Standard at $19 per year unlocks contact forms, email capture, form submissions sent to your inbox or webhook. For freelancers, small businesses, and creators wanting to capture inquiries without a separate tool, Carrd handles this natively. Shelfy doesn't have native forms.
Embedded commerce widgets. Stripe, PayPal, Gumroad widgets embed natively on Pro Standard. You can sell a digital product, accept donations, or take consultation payments directly from a Carrd page. Not a full storefront, but enough for many creators selling one or two things.
Annual pricing model. $19 per year is less than two months of Linktree Pro. For creators tired of monthly subscriptions, Carrd's pricing model alone is a relief. Pro Lite at $9 per year removes branding for personal projects. For context on why Linktree's monthly pricing keeps rising, see why Linktree is so expensive.
Genuine indie-hacker pedigree. Solo-developed, bootstrapped, no VC pressure to monetize aggressively. The tool has stayed cheap and focused for nearly a decade because the founder wanted it that way. For creators who care about supporting independent software, Carrd is one of the cleaner stories in the category.
Better SEO control on Pro Standard and above. Custom meta tags, canonical URLs, custom favicons. Not as good as a real CMS for serious SEO, but meaningfully better than most link-in-bio tools, which typically have zero SEO controls.
If most of those describe your needs, Carrd is probably the right choice and you can stop reading.
Where Shelfy wins
The other side.
Free forever, every meaningful feature included. Carrd's free plan limits you to 3 sites, 50 components per page, mandatory "Made with Carrd" branding, and no custom domain. To get rid of branding alone, you upgrade to Pro Lite at $9 per year. To get a custom domain, Pro Standard at $19 per year. Shelfy's free plan includes everything: unlimited collections, custom domains, voting, follow + notify, the API, team collaboration, the Chrome extension, no Shelfy branding. Not a freemium funnel, the actual product.
Built for organized link collections, not flat layouts. Carrd builds one-page sites where links are buttons or list items in whatever section you place them. Shelfy treats links as first-class objects with categories, tags, search, drag-and-drop reordering, and auto-fetched preview metadata (OG images, titles, descriptions). For creators with 30+ links to organize, the difference between Shelfy's structured collections and Carrd's flat-page layout becomes obvious quickly.
Community voting on link collections. No other tool in the link-in-bio category has this, and Carrd specifically isn't built for it. Visitors upvote what they find valuable, and your collection reorders to surface what your audience actually responds to. For curators, recommendation creators, and newsletter operators, voting transforms what a public link page does.
Unlimited collections per account. Carrd's free plan caps at 3 sites; Pro Lite stays at 3; Pro Standard goes to 10; Pro Plus goes to 25. Shelfy's free plan includes unlimited collections. If you organize content by topic, by audience, by campaign, or by season, that ceiling matters.
Public-page layout switcher (Card and List). Shelfy public collections include a viewer-toggleable switch between Card view (rich previews with auto-fetched OG images and descriptions) and List view (compact). The viewer chooses how they want to browse. Carrd's pages are whatever you designed; the viewer experiences the layout you set.
Auto-fetched preview metadata. Paste a URL into Shelfy and it grabs the title, description, and OG image automatically. No manual image upload, no manual description writing. Carrd requires you to add and arrange every piece of media manually. For curators adding 20 links per week, the time savings compound.
Chrome extension for tab-saving. Click the extension icon, save every open browser tab into a Shelfy collection in one click. Carrd doesn't address this use case at all. For creators who research, curate, and reference resources continuously, it eliminates the bookmark graveyard problem.
Collection redirects. Turn any collection into a smart redirect URL. Share yourdomain.com/now everywhere, then update the destination anytime without changing the public URL. Carrd doesn't have an equivalent at any tier.
Real REST API with bulk import. Shelfy exposes 1,000 requests per hour with bulk import for entire collections in a single API call. Bearer token auth, full CRUD operations, complete docs at /api/v1. Carrd's Zapier integration requires Pro Plus at $49 per year and has more limited capabilities.
Follow + notify on public collections. Visitors can follow any Shelfy collection with one click and get instant in-app notifications when new links are added. Rate-limited (max 1 per collection every 30 minutes) to prevent spam. Carrd has no equivalent because it builds static pages, not living collections.
Team collaboration on free. Shared collections with multiple editors, permission controls, public/private toggle. Carrd is built around individual sites managed by one account; team workflows require manual coordination.
A note: Carrd updates features and tier inclusions periodically. Verify against Carrd's pricing page before making decisions. Pricing reflected here is current as of May 2026.
Already convinced? Shelfy is free forever, every feature included. Try it now
Or keep reading for the use-case verdicts and the "use both" pattern.
The pricing reality
This is where most comparison posts get it wrong by treating the costs as direct equivalents. They aren't.
Carrd's pricing is genuinely fair for what it does. $19 per year for Pro Standard works out to less than $2 per month. For a one-page website with custom domain, contact forms, payment widgets, and SEO controls, that's one of the best deals in software. The Pro Lite tier at $9 per year is fine for personal projects where branding removal is the only paid feature you need.
Carrd's free plan is technically free but practically constrained. No custom domain, mandatory "Made with Carrd" branding, 3-site limit, 50 components per page. Useful for testing the editor or hobby projects, but most creators outgrow these limits quickly.
Shelfy's free plan is the actual product. Unlimited collections, custom domains free, all features included. There is no upsell tier because the business model doesn't depend on extracting fees from creators or on feature-gating.
The honest pricing comparison:
If you only need link organization, Shelfy free vs Carrd Pro Standard ($19/year) saves you money on Shelfy and gets you a better-fit product.
If you need a real one-page website with forms and payment widgets, Carrd Pro Standard at $19/year is the right tool and Shelfy doesn't replace it.
If you need both, the combined cost of Shelfy free and Carrd Pro Standard is $19/year, which is still cheaper than nearly any monthly link-in-bio subscription on its own.
This isn't a "Carrd is too expensive" critique. Carrd is appropriately priced for what it does. The point is just that Carrd and Shelfy aren't substitutes; they solve different problems.
Use-case verdicts
"I'm a freelancer building a portfolio site with a contact form"
Carrd Pro Standard, $19 per year. This is exactly Carrd's home turf. Real one-page site, custom domain, contact form, polished design. Shelfy isn't built for this.
"I'm a creator with a long list of resources, articles, and recommendations to share"
Shelfy. Categories, tags, voting, search, follow + notify. Carrd would render this as a flat list of buttons; Shelfy treats it as the actual organized collection it is.
"I'm a podcaster with episodes, sponsors, and a guest archive to organize"
Shelfy. See the link in bio for podcasters guide for the full breakdown. Carrd can technically build a podcaster page, but you're manually arranging every episode link with no auto-organization.
"I'm a newsletter operator with 50+ back issues to surface"
Shelfy. Sub-collections by topic, voting, follow + notify on new issues. Carrd is the wrong shape for archive discoverability.
"I'm pre-launching a SaaS product and need a coming-soon page with email capture"
"I'm a coach with one signature service and want a real homepage"
Carrd Pro Standard. Hero section, about, testimonials, booking link, contact form. Real website. Shelfy doesn't replace this.
"I'm an Instagram or TikTok creator with mostly social bio traffic"
Shelfy. Faster to update, voting tells you what your audience cares about, unlimited collections lets you segment by content type. Carrd works but you'll be manually maintaining a flat layout.
"I'm a designer who cares about pixel-level visual control"
Carrd Pro Plus, $49 per year. Custom code, custom typography choices, full layout freedom. Shelfy's auto-styled Card view will feel constraining if visual customization is your priority.
"I'm an affiliate marketer organizing links by category"
Shelfy. Categories, tags, voting, click analytics. Carrd would force you to manually arrange every entry.
"I run a small team or agency"
Shelfy for shared resource collections (team collaboration is on the free plan). Carrd for individual landing pages and client mini-sites. Different tools for different needs; running both makes sense.
"I want my bio link to actually look like a designed page, not a list"
Either, depending on what you mean. If "designed page" means full layout control and visual sophistication, Carrd Pro Standard. If "designed page" means rich previews with auto-fetched images and clean typography, Shelfy's Card view delivers that without any manual setup.
The "use both" pattern
For creators who need both a real website and a curated link collection, the right answer is often both. They genuinely don't overlap.
The pattern:
Carrd as your homepage or about page. $19 per year for Pro Standard. Lives at yourname.com or similar. Real website with hero, about, contact form, social links, payment widgets if relevant.
Shelfy as your audience-facing curation surface. Free. Lives at links.yourname.com (free custom domain on Shelfy) or as a section linked from your Carrd site. Where your back-issue archive, recommendation lists, resource collections, and audience-voted content lives.
How they connect: Your Carrd homepage includes a button or section linking to your Shelfy collection (or directly to specific Shelfy sub-collections). Visitors who want to know who you are land on Carrd; visitors who want to dig into your content land on Shelfy. Each tool does what it's good at.
Why this beats running everything on Carrd: Carrd is built for static one-page sites. Once you have 30+ links to organize across multiple topics, Carrd becomes a maintenance burden. Every new resource is a manual edit. Shelfy treats those links as first-class objects with auto-organization.
Why this beats running everything on Shelfy: Shelfy doesn't build websites. If you need an actual homepage with hero, about, testimonials, contact form, you need a website builder. Carrd does that cheaply.
Combined cost: $19 per year, which is less than one month of most monthly-subscription competitors.
This is the pattern many creators settle into after running both separately and realizing they're solving different problems.
What this comparison didn't cover
Some honest limits:
Carrd's design depth at Pro Plus. The $49 per year tier supports custom code embeds, password protection, and code export, which serve more advanced use cases (gated content, password-protected client previews, custom-built integrations). For most creators these aren't relevant; for some they're decisive.
Carrd's animation and transition options. Real, varied, and well-designed. Shelfy doesn't try to compete on motion design.
Shelfy's commerce gap. Shelfy doesn't have any storefront or payment processing. If you need to sell, you'll link out to Stripe, Gumroad, Lemon Squeezy, or another commerce tool. Carrd has at least basic commerce widget support on Pro Standard.
Shelfy's design customization gap. Shelfy collections are auto-styled with consistent design. There's no custom CSS, no custom typography choices beyond what's built in. For creators who want full visual control, Carrd is the right tool.
Carrd's lack of voting, follow, notification, or audience-input features. Carrd is fundamentally a static site builder. The interactive audience-input features Shelfy has don't exist on Carrd.
Performance under traffic spikes. Both tools are reasonably reliable, but neither has been stress-tested in this comparison. Read user reports for current sentiment.
The real question to ask yourself
Forget feature lists for a moment. The question that decides this is straightforward:
Are you building a website, or are you building a curation surface?
If you're building a website (homepage, landing page, portfolio, contact form, payment widget on a page), Carrd is the right tool. Pay the $19 per year for Pro Standard, accept that one-page constraint as a feature, and use what's genuinely one of the best deals in software.
If you're building a curation surface (organized link collection, audience-facing resource library, archive of recommendations or content, anything where the links themselves are the content), Shelfy is the right tool. Free forever, designed for that workflow specifically.
If you're building both, run both. The combined cost is $19 per year, which is still cheaper than almost any monthly competitor on its own.
Most creators who think they need to pick one are conflating two different use cases. Separating them clarifies the choice and often points to the "use both" pattern as the right answer.
Try Shelfy free
If you're a curator, podcaster, newsletter operator, recommendation creator, or any creator whose value is sharing organized collections of links, Shelfy is free forever, every feature included.
Not specifically. Carrd is a one-page website builder that creators sometimes use as a link-in-bio because it can build any kind of one-page site. The tool itself doesn't have link-in-bio-specific features like categories, tags, voting, or auto-fetched previews. If you're using Carrd primarily as a link-in-bio, you're using a website builder for a curation problem.
Is Shelfy free forever, or is there a paid tier?
Shelfy is free forever with all features included. There is no paid tier. Unlimited collections, custom domains, voting, follow + notify, the API, team collaboration, and the Chrome extension are all on the free plan. Their FAQ explicitly answers "Seriously, completely free? What's the catch?" with "Zero catch."
What's Carrd's free plan actually like?
Carrd's free plan limits you to 3 sites, 50 components per page, mandatory "Made with Carrd" branding visible on every page, and no custom domain (you're stuck on a .carrd.co URL). It's enough for testing the editor or hobby projects but not for professional use. Pro Lite at $9 per year removes branding; Pro Standard at $19 per year unlocks custom domains and forms.
Can I sell digital products on either tool?
Carrd Pro Standard ($19 per year) and above can embed Stripe, PayPal, and Gumroad widgets, which lets you accept payments from a Carrd page. It's not a full storefront, but enough for selling one or two digital products. Shelfy doesn't have any storefront or payment processing; you'd link out to a commerce tool like Gumroad or Lemon Squeezy.
Does Carrd have categories, tags, or search for links?
No. Carrd builds static one-page sites where you manually arrange elements. There's no automatic link organization, no tagging system, no search across links. If you need 30+ links organized by topic, Carrd becomes a manual maintenance burden quickly. Shelfy treats categories, tags, and search as first-class features.
Can Shelfy build a homepage or landing page?
Not really. Shelfy is built for organized link collections, not for one-page websites with hero sections, custom layouts, contact forms, or marketing copy. If you need a homepage, Carrd Pro Standard is the right tool. The "use both" pattern (Carrd as homepage, Shelfy as curation surface) is what many creators settle into.
Which tool is better for SEO?
Carrd Pro Standard and above offer custom meta tags and basic SEO controls; Pro Plus adds canonical URLs. Shelfy supports custom domains free on the free plan, which means audience equity accumulates on a domain you control. For serious organic traffic strategies, a real CMS is the right tool; for link-in-bio level SEO needs, Shelfy's free custom domain is a meaningful advantage over tools that only offer branded subdomains.
Can I password-protect content on either tool?
Carrd Pro Plus ($49 per year) supports password protection on individual sites. Shelfy supports private collections (visible only to collaborators) but not password-protected public collections with a shared password. If public-but-gated content is a requirement, Carrd Pro Plus is the right tool.
Does Carrd have a Chrome extension or browser integration?
No. Carrd is a site builder; you manage it through the web editor. Shelfy has a Chrome extension that lets you save open browser tabs to collections in one click. For research-driven creators, that's a meaningful workflow difference.
Is the "use both" pattern actually common?
Yes. Carrd as a personal homepage or landing page combined with Shelfy as a link-collection surface is a natural split because the tools solve genuinely different problems. Combined cost of $19 per year for Carrd Pro Standard plus Shelfy free is cheaper than almost any single monthly subscription in the category.
Last reviewed: May 2026. Carrd updates pricing and tier features periodically. Verify against Carrd's pricing page before making decisions.
